Saturday, 12 January 2013
Critical Reflection on Professional Practitioner Inquiry
Critical Reflection on Professional
Practitioner Inquiry
I have done a lot of reflection
throughout this module. Mainly
reflecting on my prior experience interning.
Developing the questions ‘is the experience worthwhile?’ ‘did I gain the
necessary experience to help further my career?’. All of my previous work experience was in a
completely contrasting industry – Musical Theatre, therefore I needed the unpaid
internships, for me they were compulsory.
I wanted my awards
title to be reflective of my current practice, and a subject I felt
passionately about. I initially
discussed the idea of further developing the ethical practices
within retail buying, but I dismissed this topic soon after, due to the ethical
issues that would potentially arise (Appendix A).
After further thought
and many discussions with both my advisor and S.I.G groups, I decided on the
following title, reflecting both my knowledge and learning,
"Interning as a platform for career
development".
I am open to all viewpoints on the
topic of internship, so am conscious that being biased will not be an issue. I
am not looking for specific answers to my questions, the more variation the
better, as no 2 internships are the same, and no 2 practitioners share the same
experience. Hopefully these results will
lead me to the truest data outcome possible.
After reading and working through
the tasks in Reader 5, ‘Professional Ethics’ and discussing in sessions, we began
looking in depth at ethical practice, focusing on ethics in a working
environment (Appendix Bi & Bii), what the codes of practice are, and how we
will link these to our inquiry.
I will be interviewing
people and inviting attendees to my focus group from different career paths
including from the world of retail, psychology, performance and HR.
I will not need to
contact any companies in terms of ethical practices, as my ethical practices
will lie alone with how I conduct myself (Appendix D).
Throughout Reader 6, ‘Tools of
Professional Inquiry’, we discussed how to ethically gain the information and
data needed to complete our inquiries.
The tools available to use were focus groups, surveys, interviews and
observation. After discussing each tool in detail uncovering the
positives and negatives with relation to my own inquiry, I dismissed surveys
and observation as not being quite suitable or practical for my inquiry, and piloted
both focus groups and Interviews separately (Appendix C). On reflection, both tools worked perfectly
for my inquiry, and in my opinion, using a combination of tools can ensure the
analysis of data collected is reliable and can produce valid results, which is
inevitably my objective.
I learnt a lot from my pilot’s
including how to improve certain techniques used in holding the focus group
mainly, which I will carry forward to Module 3.
My inquiry required qualitative
data instead of quantitive. My aim is to
un-cover attitudes and feelings towards Internship, using the more sympathetic
tools - pushing my candidates further and helping un-cover the honest views
behind interning.
My candidates will be kept anonymous, and
gain a level of trust and understanding that I would not do anything
detrimental to compromise their careers.
In summary, during this module I discovered
the level of depth of information I could capture from my inquiry. Through many discussions with others, either
in campus sessions, via S.IG.’s or email, I managed to choose the most relevant
methods of tools for my inquiry. Completing
tasks throughout the readers, enabled me to focus on a topic of huge importance
to me resulting in my inquiry title.
References
Bell, J. (2005) Doing Your Research Project (4th ed), Milton Keynes:
Open University Press.
BAPP (Arts), Reader 4, Developing
Lines Of Professional Inquiry, WBS 3630
Appendices
Appendix
A
Sunday, 25 November 2012
4D
Appendix Bi
Tuesday, 6 November 2012
My first campus session – module 2
Appendix Bii
Friday, 16 November 2012
Module 2 –
Reader 5 – Task 5B
Appendix C
Friday, 16 November 2012
Module 2 – 4c
Part B, Questions developed further
Appendix
D
Sunday, 25
November 2012
5D
Sunday, 25 November 2012
5D
Now that I have chosen my awards title, I can now look into the ethical dimensions of conducting my inquiry.
I will be interviewing people from different career paths including from the world of retail, performance and HR.
I will be conducting both one on one interviews and and focus groups.
I will not need to contact any companies in terms of ethical practices, my ethical practices will lie alone with how I conduct myself in the interviews and focus group. I will be un-biased as to enable me to have the truest outcome possible.
I will conduct all my ethical practice as I have discussed previously in my blog -
http://hannahzapala.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/my-campus-session-module-2-i-attended.html
Looking at my inquiry, I think the issues I will need to look at are mainly confidentiality. I would not want any of my colleagues and friends that I interview to feel pressurised that their opinions will lead to anything detrimental for their personal careers.
I will need to be conscious, that although I will know my interviewee's the atmosphere needs to be kept professional - formal but friendly, I want them to feel relaxed and open to discuss all areas of the inquiry.
I havent had many comments or emails with regards to my proposed SIG. So any comments are now more welcome than before - have I covered all of the ethics of my inquiry? I myself cannot think of anything I am missing, but please feel free to point anything out as I want to ensure I have all corners covered!
Now that I have chosen my awards title, I can now look into the ethical dimensions of conducting my inquiry.
I will be interviewing people from different career paths including from the world of retail, performance and HR.
I will be conducting both one on one interviews and and focus groups.
I will not need to contact any companies in terms of ethical practices, my ethical practices will lie alone with how I conduct myself in the interviews and focus group. I will be un-biased as to enable me to have the truest outcome possible.
I will conduct all my ethical practice as I have discussed previously in my blog -
http://hannahzapala.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/my-campus-session-module-2-i-attended.html
Looking at my inquiry, I think the issues I will need to look at are mainly confidentiality. I would not want any of my colleagues and friends that I interview to feel pressurised that their opinions will lead to anything detrimental for their personal careers.
I will need to be conscious, that although I will know my interviewee's the atmosphere needs to be kept professional - formal but friendly, I want them to feel relaxed and open to discuss all areas of the inquiry.
I havent had many comments or emails with regards to my proposed SIG. So any comments are now more welcome than before - have I covered all of the ethics of my inquiry? I myself cannot think of anything I am missing, but please feel free to point anything out as I want to ensure I have all corners covered!
4D
It has taken me a long time to think about my awards title. I wanted it to be something which was reflective to my current practice, and what I felt passionately about rather than it just being a means to an end. After much thought and conversations with my advisor Rosemary I have finally come to a decision.
I initially discussed the idea of further developing the ethical practices within retail buying or retail in general, but I would have had to be very careful in terms of the positives and negatives I chose to discuss, disclosing information without highlighting any retailers in particular - would this have been ethical?? I am still early on on my career path and could not afford to investigate further into a company which could then be detrimental to me in my personal practice. Although the subject interests me hugely, I have chosen to look at a slightly different inquiry which is also a passion of mine as I have subjected myself to this first-hand (which I don't see necessarily as a negative from a personal point of view) as well as a lot of other colleagues both in my industry and different industries - it will be interesting to investigate this further!
"Interning as a platform for career development".
I believe the above title reflects my knowledge and learning, as I have interned in various companies which I do truly feel has led me to where I am today.
I am excited to get my pilot tools organised and interview different people from various career paths including colleagues in the retail world, performers and HR managers, as i feel I need to see the intern world from many different viewpoints to enable me to gather enough substantial evidence to carry out a full and informative inquiry.
It has taken me a long time to think about my awards title. I wanted it to be something which was reflective to my current practice, and what I felt passionately about rather than it just being a means to an end. After much thought and conversations with my advisor Rosemary I have finally come to a decision.
I initially discussed the idea of further developing the ethical practices within retail buying or retail in general, but I would have had to be very careful in terms of the positives and negatives I chose to discuss, disclosing information without highlighting any retailers in particular - would this have been ethical?? I am still early on on my career path and could not afford to investigate further into a company which could then be detrimental to me in my personal practice. Although the subject interests me hugely, I have chosen to look at a slightly different inquiry which is also a passion of mine as I have subjected myself to this first-hand (which I don't see necessarily as a negative from a personal point of view) as well as a lot of other colleagues both in my industry and different industries - it will be interesting to investigate this further!
"Interning as a platform for career development".
I believe the above title reflects my knowledge and learning, as I have interned in various companies which I do truly feel has led me to where I am today.
I am excited to get my pilot tools organised and interview different people from various career paths including colleagues in the retail world, performers and HR managers, as i feel I need to see the intern world from many different viewpoints to enable me to gather enough substantial evidence to carry out a full and informative inquiry.
20th November - 3rd Campus Session & 6b
I attended the 3rd campus session on Tuesday with Alan, and it really helped put a lot of things in perspective for me with regards to module 2.
Firstly, I was not aware that we were able to choose part of the tile of our degree, quite literally - BA Hons in Professional Practice (Arts) - the Arts section of the title can be linked to whatever you think necessary within reason. I am writing this info on my blog, as I was completely unaware of this, and for those of you who can't attend every session, you may have been unaware of this really important factor such as I was! It's important to discuss with your advisor sooner rather than later as the title you wish to use has to be approved via a board at the university beforehand.
We discussed parts of reader 6, including how to gain information for us to complete our inquiries including focus groups, surveys, interviews and observation. Which one works for you best in terms of the type of inquiry you will be carrying out.
We split up into groups, and my group looked at the positives and negatives of each tool which we then filmed and can be found on Alan's blog below -
http://adurrant.blogspot.co.uk
I looked at the positives and negatives of using the survey tool-
Positive
-You may encounter a larger responsive audience, simply due to the physical survey being less time consuming .
-By carrying out a survey the candidates can be anonymous, and therefore have a tendency to be more truthful.
-A survey can be precise and direct to the point, where-as in interview, one can have a tendency to go off on a tangent, with a survey this is not he case.
Negative
-Authenticity can be a big negative, as there can b not enough care or though gone into the survey.
-You may encounter incomplete data.
-Non-egagement is a large factor as you do not have face to face interaction with your audience.
We actually decided in the session, that we had loosely carried out a focus group, conversing supporting each other- inputting ideas, which interestingly enough were actually all closely linked, even though our inquiries are all very different. In effect this was our pilot focus group!
Personally, my inquiry I think is calling out for one on one personal interviews, as interning is such a personal experience that I will not gather the information I quite need from a survey, I need to have more detailed experiences to gage the level of information I need.
I cannot observe people in the workplace of their internship as this will not only not be very convenient, it would be difficult for me to gain access into a workplace due to rules in place within companies.
I may hold a focus group, as it would be good to hear peoples experiences and how they bounce off one another - it would be great to be part of a debate of the positives and negatives of interning.
Personally, my inquiry I think is calling out for one on one personal interviews, as interning is such a personal experience that I will not gather the information I quite need from a survey, I need to have more detailed experiences to gage the level of information I need.
I cannot observe people in the workplace of their internship as this will not only not be very convenient, it would be difficult for me to gain access into a workplace due to rules in place within companies.
I may hold a focus group, as it would be good to hear peoples experiences and how they bounce off one another - it would be great to be part of a debate of the positives and negatives of interning.
Friday, 16 November 2012
Module 2 – Reader 5 – Task 5B
Module 2 – Reader 5 – Task 5B
An interesting
article I found online conveys what workplace ethics actually are, I thought
this would be interesting to share with everyone, as it really helped me almost
‘label’ what we actually decipher as ‘ethics’…
“Workplace
ethics are codes of conduct that influence the development of an ethical
culture within the workplace. Going beyond what is considered legal in the area
where the business operates, workplace ethics inspire communication between
employees, allow for respect to be extended to each person within the
organization, and promote customer relationships that are based on honesty and
integrity. While there are core elements that tend to define a work-based code of ethics, the specific expressions of
these central values vary from one corporate setting to the next”.
“Along
with being shaped by laws and regulations, workplace ethics are also influenced
by business ethics For example, ethical business practices would include
actions such as not using marketing materials or campaigns that mislead
consumers. Workplace ethics would also involve establishing and operating
support networks such as wellness programs that help employees be
healthy and happy. Ethics of this type would also involve the conscious effort
to cultivate a working environment where people want to come to work and be
productive because of pride in what they do for a living”.
“While
businesses tend to comply with laws and regulations set by local jurisdictions,
not every company sees the need to develop workplace ethics that affirm the
worth of employees and motivate them to be productive on the job. When a
company chooses to do no more than what is required by local law, the chances
of heavy employee turnover are much higher. In addition, it is easier for
cliques to develop among certain groups of employees, a state that can often
undermine productivity and cost the company a great deal in terms of time and
revenue generation”.
With regards to my personal ‘code of conduct’, the
retailer I work for has a very strong ‘code of ethics and behavior’ which you
can read in the link and also pdf link below.
published September 2012
Both of the above documents
are viewable for anyone, proving how passionate we are for what we stand for.
“We are committed
to doing the right thing, the right way”.
Marc Bolland Chief Executive
All M&S employees are required to
adhere to the Code and the policies it refers to. We all have a responsibility
to protect the Company’s reputation in everything we do and say. We are to
ensure that we have thoroughly read, understood and act in accordance with the
Code and the various policies embedded in it. M&S want their employees to
understand why this is important and what is expected of all employees.
It is imperative that we represent ourselves properly,
as otherwise it can be detrimental to the brand. I am passionate to work for the brand and
therefore agree and apply myself daily to the code of conduct expected of
me. It sounds a little regimented when I
say it like this, but working for one of the UK’s most ethically proven
companys Is brilliant as I can literally practice what I preach!
I have also found a couple of interesting articles
on ethical trading standards, showing how ethics are applied within retail –
A brilliant
quote taken from the above is…
“In future, ethics should be as important as quality for
all businesses”.
I agree whole heartedly with the above article,
and if you are interested in trading standards, read the above for an insight!
Another
interesting article with regards to ethical standards, and how Marks & Spencer set out plans to become the world's most
sustainable retailer by 2015 can be found in the below it includes a little
info on PLAN A (http://plana.marksandspencer.com/about),
our strategy launched in January 2007, setting out 100 commitments to
achieve in 5 years. We've now extended Plan A to 180 commitments to achieve by
2015, with the ultimate goal of becoming the world's most sustainable major
retailer.
Through Plan A we are working with our customers and our
suppliers to combat climate change, reduce waste, use sustainable raw materials,
trade ethically, and help our customers to lead healthier lifestyles. It has
been named Plan A, as unfortunately there is no Plan B!
http://www.standard.co.uk/business/marks--spencer-aims-to-lead-world-in-ethical-trading-6728440.html
Module 2 – Rader 5 – Task A
Module 2 – Rader 5 – Task A
Definition of ethics
plural noun
•
1 [usually
treated as plural] moral principles that govern a person’s behaviour or the
conducting of an activity: medical ethics also enter into the question
2 [usually
treated as singular] the branch of knowledge that deals with moral
principles: neither metaphysics nor ethics is the home of religion
I have never been asked to consider my ethics
within the workplace quite so literally.
I guess, subconsciously you apply your ethics on a daily basis, but they
are not necessarily rules you abide by, they are simply a way of ones life. My ethics may alter
slightly from my personal life to my professional life, as in the workplace I
adhere to the code of conduct within my practice that are set in place, they
will also vary on the situations I come across. In theory I would say my ethics in the
workplace are affected by my peers, as I have learnt the do’s and dont’s from
what is deemed acceptable and unacceptable – for example to address suppliers
in a polite and professional manner, not ‘You alright babe’.
I have listed below in a
general format the ethics I currently implement in my practice.
Behaviour:
I mange peers below me, therefore I treat others
how I wish to be treated and try to lead by example, learning from those above
me.
We have a great working atmosphere in the
workplace, but there must be boundaries that all are aware of between work and
play. It has to be addressed to ensure
these boundaries are not threatened – in an industry such-as mine deadlines are
so tight there is no room for movement, therefore there has to be a level of
constant professionalism simply to ensure the ‘job gets done’, as each
individual is wholly accountable.
Communication:
Communication is key I would think to any job role. It is easy to fall under the rails and become
lost in an industry particularly one like mine and my previous industry working
in the theatre – in large industries such as these, especially when you are at
the bottom of your career ladder your are that little fish playing in the big
pond. Stay in tune with yourself.
It is important that I stay involved with my team in terms of
communicating - ask questions and share problems and I will inevitably continue
to learn and grow as a professional.
Language:
I must always be aware of the language I use in
the workplace, as obviously offensive language is simply not acceptable. I am friends with many people in the
workplace, but must always be aware of maintaining that professional level,
especially when dealing with other areas of the business and suppliers/external
peers. Again address and converse with people in the manner how I would wish to
be spoken to.
Punctuality:
In a world where you are the hands behind the product and customers
are reliant on you for their trusted products, every second is valuable. It is also linked to over-all character
impressions, in an industry where no-one has very much spare time - timing is
critical.
Presentation:
Working in an industry driven initially by fashion, it helps to be
dressed appropriately, your fashion sense I believe is also a huge part of who
you are and I’m lucky enough to work in an industry where this can be expressed
and welcomed. It is also imperative to
wear the correct clothing and shoes particularly if one is presenting to levels
of seniority.
I’m sure there are other so many 'work ethics' I have not mentioned that
I will come to realise I practice daily as my study continues. Once I continue to breakdown my ethics and find
out the expected ‘code of conduct’ at my workplace, I will be able to distinguish
my ‘ethical actions’ even further.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
